Picking a hotel in New York is the easy part. Picking the right neighborhood is what decides whether you love the trip. Most hotels are in Manhattan, but Brooklyn and the Financial District can give you more room for your money. So start with the area, then compare hotels.
Midtown: the easy answer for a first trip
Only a few days and you want the classics? Stay in Midtown. Times Square, Broadway and the main train stations are all close, so you spend less time getting places and more time seeing them. The catch: it is loud and crowded from morning until late at night. If that sounds like too much, keep reading.
Lower Manhattan: calmer evenings
The Financial District and Tribeca have good subway access and are often calmer on weekends. Pick this area if you like coming back to a quiet street after a long day. The trade-off is fewer late-night options right outside your door.
Williamsburg and DUMBO: a more local feel
Think restaurants, skyline views and a short subway ride into Manhattan. Brooklyn can give you more room for the money, and it suits people who would rather explore neighborhoods than tick off landmarks.
Upper West Side: parks, museums and an easier pace
It is residential, right next to Central Park and the big museums. It is a good fit for families, and for anyone who finds Midtown too much.
Getting around
Good news: you do not need a car in Manhattan. The subway covers almost everything. So choose a hotel near a subway line you will actually use. That matters more than being a few blocks closer to one attraction.
From our experience
My wife and I spent a week on vacation in the Secaucus-Meadowlands area of New Jersey. We rented a car from Enterprise, a modern Volkswagen Taos that we really liked, and we could share our Waze navigation on the car’s screen. To get into New York we took an Uber instead of driving, because of the traffic and all the tolls. There was still a lot of traffic, but the ride through the tunnel between New Jersey and Manhattan was quick, and our driver told us we were going under the water. It was a first for me. We never regretted taking an Uber: when we were there, many sidewalks were under construction because buildings were being renovated, and parking was hard. New Yorkers say the same: because of all this, they prefer to buy bus or subway passes and leave their cars at home, since it is faster and cheaper. Our hotel room also had a very spacious bathroom, almost like a second room. We went in October, and the cold was already strong in New York, while the warm weather back home in Georgia felt good. The room cost about $460 for the whole week, which we thought was a good price. Prices change a lot with the season and the dates, so check the total for yours.
When to go
April to June and September to November are usually mild, but by October it can already feel cold, so pack warm layers. December is festive but busy, so book earlier if you travel then.
Still undecided? Use this
- Short on time and want the classics: Midtown.
- Want quieter evenings with good subway access: Lower Manhattan.
- Prefer a local feel and skyline views: Williamsburg or DUMBO.
- Museums, parks or traveling with children: Upper West Side.
Once you have picked an area, compare hotels for your exact dates. Prices and availability change from day to day, so always check the total price before you book.
Ready to plan New York?
Read our full New York guide and compare hotels, rental cars and restaurants for your dates with our partners.
Affiliate disclosure: Cityvana earns a commission when you book through some of the links on our site, at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability are shown by our partners and may change. Read the full disclosure.